[et_pb_section admin_label=”section”]
[et_pb_row admin_label=”row”]
[et_pb_column type=”4_4″][et_pb_text admin_label=”Text”]

2025 NFL DRAFT PROS…
 
Notifications
Clear all

Player Breakdown 2025 NFL DRAFT PROSPECT PROFILE #11- Shemar Stewart

9 Posts
4 Users
3 Reactions
540 Views
Erick V
Posts: 894
Topic starter
(@evolz3737)
Noble Member
Joined: 2 years ago
2025 NFL DRAFT
PROSPECT PREVIEW SERIES

 

Even with the NFL draft months away, it is never to early to start looking at some of the many prospects that will be future NFL players. There will be more comprehensive profiles completed, and Big Boards assembled as the draft draws closer, especially after the offseason All Star events and NFL Combine are completed, and more tape is studied. However, this preview series will give a brief view at this point to some of the popular players we will hear about as potential first or second round picks in April, and if they could be a fit for the Los Angeles Chargers.

 

Shemar Stewart
DE, Texas A&M
6-6, 290

 

Shemar Stewart has the coveted size, speed, and athleticism combination that evaluators crave in NFL Edges. One would see this and think that should make him a force at the NFL level. While these traits exist, they are extremely raw and the key for him to succeed will be in refining the techniques required at the next level. What is even more of a conundrum for evaluators will be to decipher why his traits did not come close to on field production, but the flashes of brilliance are evident in the tape, and especially at the 2025 Senior Bowl.

At this point in his development, Stewart’s best attribute in his game is his speed to power. He has a tremendous get off at the line that almost takes his opponent by surprise. Once he has the upper hand after the first step, he has a great stab move and bull rush to walk back the linemen. Even with this immense power he does show some decent ankle flexion and bend around the corner occasionally as a changeup. Stewart also has decent enough hand usage and some swim and rip moves to play inside as a 3 tech as well as out on the edge. For his size, he is one hell of an athlete. He does a fantastic job in pursuit chasing plays down with effort and speed and he has a relentless motor. The speed element of his game also shows up in run defense by beating his opponent with the initial burst and then using his power to get into run lanes and reset the LOS.

With all these attributes, you would figure that Stewart would have dominated his college competition, but that is not the case. The production did not match the traits as he only amassed 6.5 sacks over 3 years of playing time, where he logged a ton of reps. Stewart needs to learn to play under control and to hone his technique to match his physical gifts. He often relied on pure talent to make plays and that was the reason he lacked top end production. With the speed the game is played at, one or two false moves can be the difference in regularly making plays.

When watching him on tape I got Ziggy Ansah vibes of a player with extreme talent that just needed to combine technique and understanding of the game along with his talent to flourish. He’s like a pitcher who can throw 99 but has no idea where the ball is going once it leaves his hand. With that being said, his freakish combination of speed and size doesn’t grow on trees, which is why I fully expect him to hear his name called anywhere from pick 11 to 32 in Rd1 of the NFL Draft.

Depending on who is returning to the Chargers Edge room will be a factor in Stewart’s fit for the 2025 season. If either/or Bosa or Mack return, I think Stewart would be a fantastic fit for the Chargers. With a year or two of refinement behind a star vet, he has the potential to become a perennial Pro Bowl player. I think he can be used like the Chiefs use Chris Jones, to pick his most favorable matchup inside or on the edge, and he would be a nightmare on the interior in NASCAR packages. With proper coaching and some diligence on his end to work at his craft, he could become the young dominant Edge player this team needs to add to the roster.


8 Replies
Buck Melanoma
Posts: 2273
(@buck-melanoma)
Famed Member
Joined: 2 years ago

Refinement may be the key word with Stewart. He’s often been able to win with raw athleticism at the college level….but refinement and being a better technician would have upped his production.

Stewart is one helluva ball of clay to mold. I’d love to see him mentored by Mack. I don’t know that he’d reach that level of pass rush ability but he could certainly be a guy that requires the opponent to scheme against. He has game wrecking ability IF he can add the technical and strategic parts to his game.


Reply
4 Replies
Erick V
(@evolz3737)
Joined: 2 years ago

Noble Member
Posts: 894

@buck-melanoma Agreed. If he could come in and be a rotational/situational rusher to start it would benefit him tremendously. If things started clicking for him at mid season, I would be all for him assuming a starting role. He just has so much talent that if he ever got it harnessed and crafted he could be a game wrecker. Sadly, there have been a bunch of guys like him that never panned out also. I’m more of a production over traits guy, but when you watch him and he flashes, he has All Pro potential which is why I would be OK with the risk. Hell, if he could become a disruptive force from a 3 tech collapsing pockets and doing the dirty work, that could be just as valuable as getting sacks.


Reply
Buck Melanoma
(@buck-melanoma)
Joined: 2 years ago

Famed Member
Posts: 2273

@evolz3737 IMO, this all depends on keeping Mack. I agree with all you said regarding production over traits….but DAMN his traits are intriguing! BUT….not sure I’d wanna spend that kinda draft capital unless Mack was still here as both a backstop and mentor.

 

Now if by chance he fell to 55 I’d run to the podium….but that’s just crazy talk.


Reply
Erick V
(@evolz3737)
Joined: 2 years ago

Noble Member
Posts: 894

@buck-melanoma 100%. Mack or Bosa as a mentor is key if thinking of selecting him.


Reply
Buck Melanoma
(@buck-melanoma)
Joined: 2 years ago

Famed Member
Posts: 2273

@evolz3737 yeah, I’d prefer Mack as a mentor but at least one of them.


Reply
Posts: 128
(@duck07)
Estimable Member
Joined: 2 years ago

Both of the Stewart’s (Josiah being the other) really intrigue me for Minter and this Defense because they’ve got that explosiveness off the snap that we seemingly would like to pair opposite of Tuli going forward. Bradyn Swinson is smaller than both of the Stewarts but also has that burst so it will be interesting to see how they might view the board at Edge.


Reply
Posts: 582
(@alisterlloyd)
Prominent Member
Joined: 2 years ago

My notes on Shemar Stewart:

  • Three Seasons for Texas A&M. 37 games, 5 sacks
  • 2024 Stats:
    • 12 games, 2 sacks, 4 hits, 33 hurries (521 snaps)
    • 79.5 Overall Grade
    • 67.2 Pass Rush Grade
    • 88.2 Run Defense Grade
    • 12.4% Pass Rush Win Rate
    • 5.5% Run-Stop Rate
    • 23.5% Missed Tackle Rate (26.9% for Career)
  • Senior Bowl standout.
  • Watched games v South Carolina (2024), Mizzou (2024) and Arkansas (2024)
  • Well-built, edge setting run defender with strong hands but limited play making skills. Stewart plays from 5-Tech most often with at least one hand in the dirt (sometimes 2). Some reps as a Defensive Tackle too (3-Tech) so plays closer to the interior than his teammate, Scourton.
  • Projects as a 4-3 Base Defensive End at the NFL level.
  • NFL teams seem to be high on him because of his rare athletic gifts. Pure film grade though leaves much to be desired. People say this guy should be a top 15 pick! 
  • Best tape I watched was v Arkansas.
  • As a pass rusher:
    • Slow get-off. Plays with more effort and size than skill.
    • Pocket pusher but lacks the speed to power conversion ability to be a pocket collapser. The hope would be that his bull rush develops.
    • Almost zero bend.
    • From the 3-Technique he flashes the ability to slant across and help teammates on loops. Individually though poses minimal threat to the QB.
    • Hands are all over the place. Doesn’t have a pass rush plan just tries to push his way through. Closest he comes to having a plan is using a long arm move.
    • Playmaking instincts lacking. Had one unabated look v South Carolina and decided to stop as the QB pump faked and threw a quick screen. Could’ve blown up the play. Struggled v Armand Membou (Mizzou).
    • On the plus side, he had 1x batted pass v South Carolina, 1x batted pass v Arkansas and another play v South Carolina where he got his hands up in the throwing lane. Shows good awareness of what the QB is doing in the pocket.
  • As a run defender:
    • Possesses optimal strength to set the edge.
    • Easily the strength of his game. Nice ability to stack and shed to affect the run game. Extends his long arms fully into the chest of the blocker to control the rep until he sheds.
    • Could become a dominant NFL run defender. But even in this area there were examples on tape where he missed opportunities to finish plays. Stretch runs/end arounds just out of his reach.
  • Side Note: A&M’s Defense is late to substitute or be in position pre-snap. Numerous plays where Stewart is getting into his alignment only moments before the ball is snapped.
  • Tape comment: https://twitter.com/TDU_Chargers/status/1890201026990600549

Reply
1 Reply
Buck Melanoma
(@buck-melanoma)
Joined: 2 years ago

Famed Member
Posts: 2273

@alisterlloyd that missed tackle rate is a huge concern, IMO.


Reply
Share:
[/et_pb_text][/et_pb_column]
[/et_pb_row]
[/et_pb_section]

Recent Chatter

  1. Wow. That’s brutal. If you add the highest US Federal tax rate (37%) to the CA state tax rate (13.3%),…

  2. https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/merrill-kelly-rejected-padres-lucrative-193413725.html So, someone said the quite part out loud. As the California tax rates continue to increase, I have to…

  3. The obvious answer is that a different group of players responded this year than last year, in part because there…

Designed with WordPress