Well, here we are sitting at 1-8 in a season where many pundits and fans proclaimed this team to be a Super Bowl contender. In theory it all made sense. Back to back 11 win seasons with playoff births. Shedding the pedestrian OC for the new age whiz kid in McDaniel. Adding the perfect pieces in free agency to the roster to execute the new offense. Adding productive players in the draft including being able to secure the elusive “blue star” player. Everything was primed for a big season, but instead it has turned into an unmitigated disaster and one of the worst seasons in franchise history. How could this happen? Who’s to blame? Were we all missing something that could have predicted this? When seasons go this bad someone has to be the fall guy, but who the real reason we are here? Ownership is the biggest flaw, but we can’t replace them. So let’s dive into the cooks in the kitchen and see who’s at fault for serving up this hot mess of a season.
Head Coach Jim Harbaugh
Jim Harbaugh is first up to dissect. When he came back the league he went back to the well to hire an OC running a decade old scheme because that’s all he knew. The league had evolved over the last 10 years that he spent at Michigan, but he didn’t. The team had early success with Telesco’s players, an easy schedule and a franchise QB who dragged the team behind with his heroics. When the lights were the brightest in the playoffs against the best teams, they didn’t just lose, but were exposed. Jim realized that the offense he was running was limited in the modern NFL and probably reached its peak, and in order to get over the hump he needed to adjust to the modern game. However, instead of deciding to hire Mike McDaniel and collaborate to blend his beliefs and what Herbert does well inside a Shanahan scheme, they came in and shoved one down his QB’s throat that doesn’t fit his skill set. This is the a downfall of hiring a CEO HC that doesn’t get himself involved with either side of the ball. He just has to hope what his coordinators do, works, because they have no way to inject a design or philosophy directly into the scheme.
Jim’s defensive hires have been very good though. Taking Minter with him from Michigan and replacing him with O’Leary has really been fantastic, but I see the theme here being that both these coaches are young and inventive in the modern game, designing things to match their personnel. They were not retread coaches forcing in the only schemes they knew, roster skills be damned. When he was with the 49ers, Jim had Vic Fangio, who is one of the premier defensive minds in the game and is another coach who designs for his personnel. Remember, Jim was a QB, so while he does not design or implement a specific offense, he has an idea of how he wants to play offense. I think he is 100% hands off with the defense, letting the DC run what they want. Again, this is a double edged sword where you need to hire the right DC, but to his credit, he has shown a knack for identifying those coaches.
Jim has also not graded out well in the NFLPA surveys where he received a C+ because players thought he wasn’t efficient with their time and was not receptive to feedback from the players, and this was after 11 win seasons. Jesse Minter received an A+ and Greg Roman received a D-. Are you noticing a theme here? I think we were expecting the hard nosed, no bullshit Harbaugh from the San Francisco days, but that is not the coach we got. As he has gotten older and after some health risks, it seems the coaching style has morphed into a positive to a fault, cliched, platitude driven approach that seems to have worn thin with players and fans alike. When Khalil Mack says he checked out of post game speeches, alarm bells should be going off in that organization. Players know when they are being bullshitted, but tolerate it with winning. It wears thin very fast in this environment and could be a factor in the 1-8 start. After all, it’s year three of this mantra and maybe not enough has really changed to get the players to buy in another season? Sometimes the proof is in the pudding.
Mike McDaniel
He is not an OC. He is a guy who designed an offense for a particular style of players and thinks it’s a panacea for every roster. Even when he was in SF as the “OC” it was a Shanahan offense and Kyle called the plays. Hell, he’s been behind Kyle in every stop they had together, so who is the real talent there? A real coach is able to understand the game on all levels and be able to design what fits the roster and plays to his players strengths. Just look at who he lobbied to bring in. Players from Miami that “knew the offense” or speed guys. He has taken Hortiz’ Rd1 pick in Hampton and made him a rotational player at best, so he could feature his speed guy Mitchell. His biggest request in the draft was a 165lb WR who ran the fastest 40 at the combine. Does that sound like someone who is an offensive mind that can create a scheme based on different personnel or a guy who only knows one way of doing something? McDaniel is not a complete coach. He is a magician with one trick in his bag. Again, players know bullshit and gimmicks. McDaniel features both in spades. Was it a coincidence players checked out in Miami? Could it be the majority reason this team is 1-8? Let’s dive further.
Joe Hortiz
Hortiz on his own could be OK, but it’s his combination with Harbaugh that is disappointing. He has had three drafts and off seasons to build the roster, but remember when he started, he said it’s his job to get the players Jim wants to build the team in his image (which we already pointed out as archaic). Jim hired him because of his relationship to the family, which in hindsight lacks any checks and balances. Hortiz was never going to override Jim on a decision, no matter what Jim says to the media. Jim might defer to him from time to time, but at the end of the day, does anyone think a guy waiting in the wings in Baltimore for 20 years to get his shot in the big chair, is ever going to override a Harbaugh family member’s decision? He will forever be Robin to Jim’s Batman. He became even more of a cuck letting McDaniel walk in the building making roster building decisions. Hortiz has been successful doing what he was trained to do in Baltimore as an assistant to the GM. He’s relatively good at maneuvering during the draft (although he shit the bed drafting Hampton instead of taking the Eagles trade), focusing on the margins, helping to mine comp picks, managing the cap and organizing the scouting department. He has been cheap to a fault in free agency and has taken a back seat to others in roster construction. Does anyone believe he has the autonomy in the building that Ozzie or DaCosta had in Baltimore? Do you think he is ever overriding Jim and now apparently McDaniel on personnel decisions? Do we really know what his belief of what an NFL roster should look like, especially seeing how his “blue star” player is performing? Has he let his arrogance or weakness have more affect on his performance?
Synopsis
When anything goes wrong or seriously underachieves, there is rarely ever one reason exclusively why it failed. It is more often a confluence of events, decisions, or circumstances. In this scenario, we have a three headed monster that formed like Voltron to become a trainwreck and at least one of these pieces, if not all three, will and should be deservedly relieved of their duties after the season. While there is a case to be made for all three my feeling is it falls on Harbaugh.
In my opinion he has not delivered on any of the promises or declarations he has spewed since he arrived in LA. Remember the “offensive linemen are weapons” and “tip of the spear” or “my priority is winning multiple Super Bowls and getting Justin Herbert to the Hall of Fame” or “we all need to raise our game to match Herbert’s greatness”. For all the talk, the OL is the worst in the league and has perennially been a bottom five unit since he arrived and we have witnessed Herbert regress over that time period as well. The tough, no nonsense coach he was hired to be has been replaced by a gentler, overly positive, older gentleman who prefers blind praise over accountability. He has not adapted to the modern NFL. His initial idea of offense was to hire back a coordinator who ran a scheme that was successful a decade earlier. When the archaic offense reached its ceiling this decade, his answer was to overcorrect and hire the avant-garde whiz kid who was all the rage and was about as far away from his football philosophy as could be. Again, when you do not design or coordinate an offense you are a prisoner of who you hire. Looking back, while this hire was universally praised, it also was made with a touch of desperation because he had no idea what to do to get to the next step on offense in today’s NFL. The only scheme he knew couldn’t get there and quite frankly didn’t match the skill set of the QB either. Now we are stuck with an OC who refuses to acclimate his playbook to the talent at his disposal and it has resulted in a broken franchise QB, an offense at the bottom of every worthwhile metric, and a HC who has no answer on how to fix it, so he keeps the same people in place.
Hortiz is a close second, because of his arrogance over the state of the roster, and his stubbornness in free agency and trade compensation. If I truly believed that he acted with autonomy as the GM, he would be the prime reason for this failure because there is no serious personnel person that believes this roster, especially at OL and WR, is even league average. Throw in the fact that he seems to not only take a backseat in personnel decisions to Harbaugh but apparently he does from the newly acquired OC as well. Can you really put the onus of blame on a yes man who lacks the conviction and fortitude to stand on his own decision making? I can’t. He is just a cog in the wheel who masquerades as the GM, but if he wants the seat in the big chair, he will be responsible for the roster even if he is just a puppet for the HC and others.
At the end of the day all the decisions fall at Harbaughs feet. He overvalued the roster. He didn’t realize the 11 win seasons were more a factor of schedule and God mode Herbert and had no idea of how to fix it to get over the hump. He chose the GM, OC and DC. If any of their failures factor into the team to regressing to 1-8, it’s his responsibility. It’s year three of his tenure and the team is closer to a rebuild than a wild card birth. Heavy is the head that wears the crown.
